Pricing and clawback of over- and under-supply of employer-provided (free-issue) materials: at the supply-contract price, not published price information or market price (GB/T 50500-2024 clause set 3.6)
Contractor-caused over-drawing of free-issue materials is charged at the corresponding supply contract's unit price on the over-drawn quantity and deducted from interim or final payments - neither at published price information nor market price; over-quantity = drawn quantity - drawing-derived quantity x (1 + effective wastage), the derivation being actual quantities from the construction drawings for unit-rate contracts and reasonable quantities from the contract drawings for lump-sum, variations excluded. Employer-caused short supply, non-conforming delivery or delay falls on the employer - extension per chapter 8 plus losses including profit; on a switch to contractor purchase, prices come from joint tendering or market enquiry, published price information serving only provisionally where no period market price exists or the dispute is large.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第3.6.1~3.6.6条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第3.2.4条、第3.7.4条
- GB/T 50500-2024 App. G.1 Table G.1.1 发包人提供材料一览表
- GB/T 50500-2024 App. A.2.2、A.2.5
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 建设工程造价鉴定作业指引 第4.5.7条
- GB/T 50875-2013 工程造价术语标准 第2.1.16条
- https://www.mohurd.gov.cn/gongkai/zc/wjk/art/2006/art_17339_156600.html
Positioning
How prices are fixed and quantities computed when clawing back or topping up free-issue (employer-supplied, contractor-installed) materials in over-supply (contractor over-draw) and under-supply (short, non-conforming or late delivery) - per GB/T 50500-2024 clause set 3.6, with the quantity-checking basis of T/ZBD 100.4-2023.
Core conclusions
1. Starting point: free-issue prices are not in the all-in unit rate
- Clause 3.6.1: "Where the employer supplies materials, it states in the tender documents their names, grades, specifications, delivery and place, and describes them in the item descriptions of the tender BOQ"; "at tendering, the prices of employer-supplied materials do not enter the all-in unit rates of the items."
- Clause 3.2.4: "The material cost of employer-supplied materials does not enter the work-item list; where the contractor installs them, the installation cost is computed", excluding the cost of delivery and unloading to site and the wastage share per Appendix G.1 Table G.1.1; "items of employer-supplied material installed by the contractor include in their all-in unit rate the contractor's own installation wastage."
- Hence the clawback is "the material money itself" - no overheads, profit or purchasing custody on top; that cost never entered the contractor's fee base.
2. Quantities: net of effective wastage before comparing
- Clause 3.6.2: the employer fixes the "effective wastage rate" in the tender documents (reasonably from similar works) and completes Appendix G.1 Table G.1.1 (quantities per the tender drawings and the national / industry standards).
- Clauses 3.6.2-3.6.3: the drawn quantity "excludes variations"; the over-draw base is - unit-rate: actual quantities from the construction drawings; lump-sum: reasonable quantities from the contract drawings. Over-draw = drawn - drawing-derived x (1 + contractual effective wastage); variation quantities never join the over-draw - they price as variations (the standard's formulas are typeset as images; symbols follow the original).
3. Prices (the core): over-supply at the supply-contract price
- Clause 3.6.3: "Where through the contractor's fault the drawn quantity exceeds the derived quantity plus contractual effective wastage, the excess material cost is the contractor's, and the employer may compute the over-drawn material cost at the unit price of the corresponding supply contract, deducting it from interim or final payments."
- Three practical points:
- "Corresponding supply contract" - same type and specification, no cross-species borrowing, no averaging published prices, not the contractor's bid price (often far below the employer's actual purchase - clawing at it would leave the employer out of pocket).
- Tax-inclusive or net per the supply contract, aligning the clawback with actual outlay; when deducting, the matching VAT is reversed too (clause 3.7.4's "the VAT of deducted amounts is deducted") - no double VAT on the clawback.
- Batch purchases at different prices: measure per batch or weight by quantity.
4. No clawback for employer-caused over-consumption (3.6.2, 3.6.3)
- "Over-draws caused by the employer's own conduct: the extra wastage is the employer's."
- "Where the employer's actual specifications differ from the tendered ones and push the wastage above the effective rate, the excess is the employer's."
5. Under-supply (short / non-conforming / late)
- Clause 3.6.5: non-conforming or off-schedule delivery, delay, or changed place/manner - the contractor helps withdraw and replace; any extension follows chapter 8 "reasonably", plus the contractor's losses including profit.
- Clause 3.6.6: switching to contractor purchase needs the contractor's written consent (reasonable objection allowed); prices "by joint tendering or market enquiry of both parties"; the corrected all-in unit rate = the installation rate from the priced BOQ + the 3.6.2 wastage rate + overheads and profit rates (from the rate build-up sheets); attendance provisions already charged are reduced per clause 8.5.
- So under-supply top-ups price at "jointly tendered or market-enquired, mutually confirmed" prices - not published price information; employer default adds extension and losses including profit.
6. The proper place of published price information (Appendix A)
- A.2.2: "Where no period market price exists or the dispute is large, the authority's published price information may be used provisionally, later trued up to actual market prices" - a provisional, dispute-fallback basis, not the clawback price.
- A.2.5: employer-recognised purchase prices as period market prices require pre-purchase submission and confirmation; employer silence within the agreed period is deemed approval and usable for adjustment.
7. Quantity checks in disputes (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.5.7) "On free-issue disputes, the appraiser first fixes actual consumption from the drawings and the consumption quota (build-up detail), then verifies purchases, issues, returns and stock with the supply department. Actual consumption = issues - stock. Issues above consumption: the excess returns with formalities; unreturned, deduct per the contract. Late supply with the employer's representative's confirmation: the confirmation sheet fixes the purchase price; consumption as above." Points: fix "should-consume" from drawings and quotas, "did-consume" from issues minus stock; return before deduction; confirmation sheets price late supplies.
8. Attendance and custody - a separate line Clause 3.6.4: delivery planning, coordination and acceptance assistance; "attendance, coordination and custody services for employer-supplied materials are at the employer's cost, chargeable in the main contractor's attendance provisions" - not netted against over-draw clawbacks.
Applicable boundaries
- For BOQ-priced "employer supplies, contractor installs" settlement and disputes; presupposes the tender documents state the scope, specifications and effective wastage (Table G.1.1).
- Not for ordinary contractor purchase; the reverse switch (contractor to employer supply) follows 3.7.4: deduct material and custody costs from the rate, other costs unchanged, VAT of deductions reversed, attendance payable per 8.5.
- Clawback at supply-contract prices presupposes the contract says so; express terms on other prices govern unless conflicting with the 3.6.3 bearing rule.
- The over-draw and corrected-rate formulas are images in the standard - verify symbols against the official text.
- Local regimes that load free-issue materials into rates first still claw back at actual supply quantities with the supply-contract price as the reference.
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 3.6.1~3.6.6, 3.2.4, 3.7.4; Appendix G.1 Table G.1.1; Appendix A.2.2, A.2.5.
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.5.7; GB/T 50875-2013 clause 2.1.16; MoHURD policy texts at https://www.mohurd.gov.cn/gongkai/zc/wjk/art/2006/art_17339_156600.html
- The four-quantity chain (planned / purchased / issued / consumed) pairs with the requisition-against-quota and stocktaking cards.