Legal liability and penalties for failing to prepare a dedicated method statement for high-risk works (sub-divisional works involving significant hazards) (MOHURD Order No. 37, amended by Order No. 47)
Failing to prepare and review a dedicated method statement for high-risk works: the enterprise is penalized under Article 65 of the Regulations on Work Safety Management of Construction Projects (order to correct within a specified time limit; if not corrected within the time limit, order to suspend business for rectification plus a fine of CNY 100,000–300,000; in serious cases, downgrade of qualification up to revocation of the qualification certificate), together with suspension of the work safety license for 30 days; the directly responsible manager and other directly responsible persons are fined CNY 1,000–5,000. Where an expert panel review is not organized for sub-divisional works involving significant hazards above a specified scale: a fine of CNY 10,000–30,000 plus suspension of the work safety license for 30 days. Where a major safety accident occurs and constitutes a crime, criminal liability is pursued under the Criminal Law; losses caused are compensated in accordance with law.
Applicable Codes
- 危险性较大的分部分项工程安全管理规定(住建部令第37号,2019年47号令修正)
- 建设工程安全生产管理条例(国务院令第393号)
- 建办质〔2018〕31号
Topic Positioning
Legal liability of the contractor and responsible persons where no dedicated method statement for high-risk works has been prepared for sub-divisional works involving significant hazards (including related violations such as failure to organize an expert panel review) — a quick reference to the penalty provisions of Articles 32–35 of MOHURD Order No. 37 (amended by Order No. 47).
Core Conclusions
Failure to prepare and review the dedicated method statement (Article 32): the enterprise is ordered to correct within a specified time limit under the Regulations on Work Safety Management of Construction Projects; if it fails to correct within the time limit, it is ordered to suspend business for rectification and fined CNY 100,000–300,000; in serious cases, its qualification is downgraded up to revocation of the qualification certificate, and the work safety license is additionally suspended for 30 days; the directly responsible manager and other directly responsible persons are fined CNY 1,000–5,000. Failure to organize an expert panel review for sub-divisional works involving significant hazards above a specified scale (Article 34): order to correct within a time limit, a fine of CNY 10,000–30,000, and suspension of the work safety license for 30 days; responsible persons fined CNY 1,000–5,000. Failure to conduct safety briefing or public announcement (Article 33) is penalized under the Work Safety Law and other laws; where the project manager fails to perform duties or to organize acceptance (Article 35): a fine of CNY 10,000–30,000. Where a crime is constituted, criminal liability is pursued under the Criminal Law; losses caused are compensated in accordance with law. Practical points: before commencement, identify against Appendices 1/2 of Jianban Zhi [2018] No. 31; "construct first, supplement the method statement later" is treated as failure to prepare; where the chief supervision engineer has not reviewed the method statement, the supervision unit is held liable under Article 57 of Order No. 393.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to contractors of building and municipal infrastructure works; the personal penalties apply to the directly responsible manager and other directly responsible persons. This is only a quick penalty reference; scope determination and the responsibility chain for preparation and approval are set out in the cited cards; provincial detailed rules may tighten the penalty standards.
Further Reading
MOHURD Order No. 37 (amended by Order No. 47) Articles 32–35; Regulations on Work Safety Management of Construction Projects (State Council Order No. 393) Articles 65 and 57; scope of sub-divisional works involving significant hazards and of those above a specified scale: Appendices 1 and 2 of Jianban Zhi [2018] No. 31.