Cost expert assessment of quantity disputes under unit-rate contracts: the stepped determination where design drawings are missing or cannot show the quantities, and the handling of missing construction or as-built drawings
With design drawings, the assessor re-computes the quantities on the drawings both parties accept and the matching measurement rules as the assessment quantities - and must re-compute the quantities actually built on the FINAL construction drawings (not the as-built drawings) (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.3.5); without drawings, or where the drawings cannot show the disputed quantities, five descending steps apply - valid joint certification, one-party certification, re-check or site inspection, inspection-based measuring, un-assessable (not measured) (clause 4.3.6); where construction or as-built drawings are missing - the subject existing, propose that the client arrange a site inspection to measure; concealed, assess by professional analysis; lost, propose the client fix who bears the adverse consequences (GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.4.1).
Applicable Codes
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 第4.3.5条、第4.3.6条
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 第4.6.3条
- GB/T 51262-2017 第5.4.1条
Topic Positioning
The stepped procedure by which the construction cost expert assessor determines the "assessment quantities" when a unit-rate contract disputes quantities and design drawings are missing or cannot show the disputed items; and the handling where construction (or as-built) drawings are lost. For disputes already in assessment needing the measurement source fixed.
Core Conclusions
1. With design drawings (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Guidance for Construction Cost Expert Assessment Practice, clause 4.3.5): for quantity disputes under unit-rate contracts, the assessor re-computes the quantities on the drawings both parties accept and the matching measurement rules as the assessment quantities. Its note: "what a unit-rate contract or unit-rate pricing fixes is the contract rate; neither provisional (simulated) quantities nor the quantities computed and issued by the tenderer (or its consultant) bind settlement or assessment - whatever the drawing changes, the quantities actually built are re-computed on the FINAL construction drawings (not the as-built drawings)."
2. Without drawings, or drawings not showing the disputed quantities (clause 4.3.6), the assessor proceeds:
- Where the parties hold a valid certified result on the disputed quantities complying with the contract, that result is the assessment quantity.
- Where a certified result exists signed by one party and the supervisor (or designer) only, and the other party neither accepts nor has valid countering evidence, that result is the assessment quantity.
- Where such a one-party certification exists and the other party objects WITH specific evidence, re-check or inspect on site and take the re-checked or inspected computation; failing both, the certification stands.
- Where no certified materials exist and the drawings cannot show the quantities, inspect on site and take the computation from the inspection.
- Where no certifications exist, the drawings show nothing, site inspection cannot fix the quantities either, and the applying party has no valid evidence, the assessor does not measure the quantities and states them in the opinion as "items unable to assess".
3. Construction (or as-built) drawings missing (GB/T 51262-2017 Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment, clause 5.4.1):
- The building subject existing - propose the client arrange a site inspection to compute the quantities and assess.
- The subject concealed - assess by professional analysis of the works' nature and whether it forms part of other works.
- The subject lost - propose the client determine who bears the adverse consequences, then assess per the client's decision.
Applicability Boundaries
- For cost assessment (disputes already in assessment) under unit-rate or unit-price contracts; lump-sum re-measurement of divisional BOQ items per GB/T 50500-2024 clause 7.2.2 sits elsewhere.
- The order of preference runs "valid certification before site inspection"; re-checks and inspections enter only absent certification or against an effectively countered one.
- Where even inspection fails and the applicant lacks valid evidence - not measured, listed as "unable to assess".
- As-built drawings never serve to re-compute quantities as built - the final construction drawings govern.
Further Reading
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023, clauses 4.3.5 and 4.3.6 (assessment technique - quantity disputes); variation cost disputes per clause 4.6.3
- GB/T 51262-2017, clause 5.4.1 (missing construction or as-built drawings)
Keywords
- construction cost expert assessment (judicial appraisal)
- 工程量争议
- 无设计图纸
- 现场勘验
- 施工图缺失
- as-built drawings
- 无法鉴定项目
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023