Determining whether vertical transport preliminaries double count the machine-shift rates of tower cranes and builder's hoists: the BOQ item coding basis, the inclusion and exclusion boundaries in provincial consumption quota chapter notes, and a method of checking whether the plant rate is included or excluded via the machine-shift content and unit of measurement of quota line items
No double counting. The machine-shift running rates of tower cranes and builder's hoists are already embedded in the pricing of the vertical transport preliminary item (GB/T 50854-2024 Table R.1.1 preliminary items, code 011601; former GB 50854-2013 Table S.3, code 011703); the vertical transport charge is the very pricing carrier of those machine-shifts, and no separate 'tower crane machine-shift charge' or 'builder's hoist machine-shift charge' may be listed. Only the parts expressly excluded by the quota chapter notes may be priced separately: off-site transport of plant, first-time erection and dismantling, subgrade bedding, track laying and removal, plus the foundations of tower cranes and hoists and the connections of cranes and hoists to the building. Determination uses a three-step check: read the inclusion and exclusion lists in the chapter notes -> check whether the labour, material and plant columns of the line item already list those machine-shifts -> check the unit of measurement and pricing basis (pricing per gross floor area is a lump-sum basis; pricing by hired machine-days must not also be charged by area).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50854-2024 房屋建筑与装饰工程工程量计算标准 App. R 第R.1.1条、第R.2.3条及Table R.1.1(措施项目,code 011601)
- GB 50854-2013 房屋建筑与装饰工程工程量计算规范 App. S Table S.3(垂直运输,code 011703)
- 江苏省建筑与装饰工程消耗量定额(2026版)垂直运输工程 章说明
- 湖南省房屋建筑与装饰工程消耗量标准(2025版)第二十章 垂直运输工程
- 陕西省新编消耗量定额(征求意见稿)3.20m(6层)以上塔式起重机施工 子目17-69~17-74
- SJG 181.5-2024 市政工程消耗量标准 Vol. 5 水处理工程 第3.1.16条
- 建筑安装工程工期定额 TY01-89-2016
Topic positioning
This card answers one of the most common double-counting disputes in cost review: whether the 'machine-shift rate' of major vertical transport plant such as tower cranes and builder's hoists and the 'vertical transport preliminaries' are two separate sums of money. It gives the coding and measurement basis at standard level, the inclusion and exclusion boundary clauses in the vertical transport chapter notes of provincial consumption quotas, and an operating method for judging 'plant rate included or excluded' by checking the machine-shift content of quota line items.
Core conclusion
1. Conclusion: no duplication, but the machine-shift running charge must be cut away from mobilisation and demobilisation, foundations and track laying and removal
The machine-shift running rate of tower cranes and builder's hoists (covering on-machine labour, power and fuel, depreciation, overhaul and maintenance) is already embedded in the pricing of the vertical transport preliminary item; the vertical transport charge is not an 'add-on item' but the pricing carrier of those machine-shifts. Listing a further 'tower crane machine-shift charge' or 'builder's hoist machine-shift charge' is double counting. What can genuinely be priced separately is only what the vertical transport charge expressly excludes - off-site transport of plant, first-time erection and dismantling, subgrade bedding, track laying and removal, plus the foundations of tower cranes and hoists and the connections of cranes and hoists to the building - and these must be priced under 'large plant mobilisation and demobilisation' type items or the corresponding quota chapters, not folded into the machine-shift rate for a second charge.
2. The basis at BOQ (measurement standard) level
GB/T 50854-2024 'Standard for measurement of building and decoration works', Appendix R, clause R.2.3, original text:
Vertical transport in this appendix covers only the major vertical transport plant used during construction of the works. Vertical transport performed with other lifting plant and manually assisted tackle is included in the work content of the corresponding divisional and elemental items.
Clause R.1.1 of the same standard: 'The item setting, units and work content of the preliminary items of the BOQ shall follow Table R.1.1.' - in the 2024 edition the preliminary items carry the overall code 011601 (Table R.1.1 preliminary items (code: 011601)), and vertical transport has been merged into the 0116xx preliminary item coding system.
The former GB 50854-2013 (superseded by GB/T 50854-2024), Table S.3: vertical transport code 011703, 'The item setting, the content of item descriptions, units of measurement and quantity take-off rules for the vertical transport BOQ items shall follow Table S.3.'
Two implications: (1) the vertical transport item takes 'operation and use of the equipment' as its work content, so the machine-shift rate is already absorbed by this preliminary item and no machine-shift item may be listed again; (2) after the coding system changed edition, when items are set out under the 2024 edition, the mobilisation, demobilisation, erection and dismantling of cranes and hoists are judged within the preliminary item system, and must not be double-listed between 'other large plant mobilisation and demobilisation with erection and dismantling' and the vertical transport item.
3. Inclusion and exclusion boundaries in the vertical transport chapter notes of provincial consumption quotas (original clauses)
'Jiangsu Province consumption quota for building and decoration works', 2026 edition, vertical transport works chapter (chapter 19), 'Notes', clause 1:
The work content of this chapter includes the vertical transport machine-shifts, the amortisation of high-pressure water pumps, up-and-down liaison communication and the like needed to complete all work items of a unit project within the current Jiangsu quota construction duration. It does not include off-site transport of the plant, first-time erection, dismantling, subgrade bedding or track laying and removal. The foundations of construction tower cranes and hoists, and the costs of connecting construction tower cranes and hoists to the building, are calculated separately.
Clause 4 of the same chapter (machine-shift content is an endogenous variable of the line item):
The vertical transport line items of this chapter assume construction with a material hoist fitted with 2 material hoists, and construction with a tower crane fitted with 1 tower crane and 1 material hoist (builder's hoist). Where the number of vertical transport machines of the building differs from the line item, the machine-shift content may be adjusted in proportion. Where only a tower crane is used for construction and no material hoist is used, the tower crane machine-shift content is taken as the material hoist content and the material hoist is deducted.
Clauses 7 and 8 of the same chapter (charging threshold and lifting already included):
- For single-storey buildings with an eaves height below 3.6m, isolated basements with a vertical transport height below 3.6m, and walls, no vertical transport machine-shifts are calculated.
- The lifting plant for general concrete elements such as precast concrete flat slabs, hollow slabs and small members is already included in the line items of this chapter.
Other key clauses of the same chapter: clause 2 defines the line items by the two indicators 'eaves height' and 'number of storeys' of the building - reaching either indicator is enough to apply the line item. Clause 3: where one project has two or more eaves heights (storey counts) using the same machine, the line item is not adjusted; where different machines are used, calculation follows the current Jiangsu duration quota for each. Clause 5: where two or more buildings share one tower crane, calculation is still by each unit project, and during the shared period the machine-shift consumption of the tower crane line item is multiplied by a coefficient (two buildings 1.15, three buildings 1.20, four buildings 1.35) and apportioned by each building's share of the shared gross floor area. Clause 6: where several buildings stand over one integral connected basement, each upper building is calculated separately and the integral connected basement follows the isolated basement line items; where the basement is constructed with the tower crane allocated to the upper building, the plant model and machine-shift consumption are adjusted to the upper allocation. Clause 9: 'cast-in-place frame' means columns, beams and slabs all cast in place; where part is cast in place and part is general precast elements, the line item is the cast-in-place frame multiplied by coefficient 0.96. Clause 10: precast concrete buildings apply the precast concrete structure line items, the crane model in the line item being adjusted per the construction method statement with no other adjustment. Clause 11: frame-tube and frame-shear structures with columns, beams, walls and slabs all cast in place follow the cast-in-place frame; tube structures follow shear walls (slip-form construction). Clause 12: single-storey factory buildings with precast roof trusses follow the precast bent-frame line items whether the columns are precast or cast in place. Clause 13: eaves height or storey count beyond the line-item calibration is calculated separately. Clause 14: walls and structures (except chimneys, water towers and silos) with a vertical transport height above 3.6m are calculated at 5% of the labour consumption of the quantity of the part above 3.6m.
'Hunan Province consumption standard for building and decoration works', 2025 edition, chapter 20, vertical transport works, 'Notes':
- This chapter covers tower cranes, builder's hoists and other vertical transport charges, in 3 sections.
- This chapter applies to buildings with an eaves height of 150m or less; for buildings above 150m the vertical transport charge may be calculated from the actual construction scheme.
- Where the eaves height of a building or the height of a structure is within 3.6m, no vertical transport plant charge is calculated.
- Where one building has several eaves heights, execution follows the different vertical heights. The first storey of a tower building, with the corresponding part of the basement, is merged into the gross floor area of the tower building.
- (1) The vertical transport plant consumption standard does not include the mobilisation and demobilisation and erection and dismantling of tower cranes and builder's hoists, their foundations, subgrade bedding and track laying and removal; where these actually occur they are calculated separately. (2) The other vertical transport charge comprehensively allows for the vertical transport costs of buildings with an eaves height within 24m.
- The vertical transport charge is in principle estimated in machine-shift quantity per the 'Duration quota for construction and installation works' (TY01-89-2016) and site needs: (1) buildings with an eaves height within 24m or within 6 storeys apply the other vertical transport charge item.
The 'quantity take-off rules' of the same chapter: (1) the other vertical transport charge is measured in square metres of gross floor area; (2) tower cranes and builder's hoists are priced by hire per machine-day; (3) for the quantity of vertical transport plant foundations, where a construction scheme exists it is calculated from the specific scheme, and where none exists by reference to the quota appendix tables.
The machine-shift quantity estimation basis of that province (machine-shift consumption standard): other concrete elements (including the lifting of concrete and formwork) count 1.12 machine-shifts per 10m3 of concrete quantity (concrete lifting 0.56 + formwork lifting 0.56); rebar works 0.05 machine-shifts per tonne; door and window works 0.23 machine-shifts per 100m2; floors, wall faces and ceiling faces 0.15 machine-shifts per 100m2 of developed finish area; roofing works (excluding the part above the rigid layer of planted roofs) 0.1 machine-shifts per 100m2 of waterproof membrane area; tiled roofs 0.175 machine-shifts per 100m2. Builder's hoists: within 100m, 0.875 machine-shifts per 100m2 of gross floor area; within 150m, 1 machine-shift per 100m2. For decoration works separately procured and built without tower cranes, the charge is taken on a labour cost base by eaves height: below 40m 4.5%, below 60m 5%, below 80m 5.5%, below 100m 5.7%, below 120m 6%, below 140m 7.8%, below 160m 8.5%, beyond 160m 9.5%.
'SJG 181.5-2024 Consumption standard for municipal works, volume 5, water treatment works', clause 3.1.16 (hire-type basis, for contrast):
The vertical transport line items are divided by vertical transport plant type, covering lorry-mounted cranes, crawler cranes and tower cranes. The vertical transport line items already allow for the machine operators and assisting labour needed during normal use and for electricity or fuel consumption; they do not include the hire charge, off-site transport, erection and dismantling or track laying and removal of the vertical transport plant, and the costs of the tower crane foundation and of connecting the tower crane to the structure are calculated separately.
4. The three-step check for 'plant rate included or excluded' via machine-shift content
Step 1 - read the chapter notes: go to the 'notes' of the vertical transport chapter of the consumption quota in force at the project location and find the 'includes...' and 'does not include...' sentences (Jiangsu clause 1 and Hunan note 5(1) are the typical pattern). Anything within 'includes' (vertical transport machine-shifts, on-machine labour, power and fuel, high-pressure water pump amortisation, up-and-down liaison communication) must not be set up as a separate line item or certified as extra machine-shifts; only items within 'does not include' (off-site transport, first-time erection and dismantling, subgrade bedding, track laying and removal, tower crane and hoist foundations and connections to the building) may be charged separately.
Step 2 - check the labour, material and plant columns of the line item: where the line-item consumption table already lists tower crane or builder's hoist machine-shifts, that plant running rate is already inside the line-item base rate and no 'plant machine-shift charge' may be listed outside the preliminaries. Example: the line items of the Shaanxi newly compiled consumption quota for 'tower crane construction above 3.20m (6 storeys)' in cast-in-place frame structures (codes 17-69 to 17-74, unit 100m2) are banded by eaves height 40/70/100/140/170/200m, and the plant column directly gives self-climbing tower cranes 400kN.m with 2.350 machine-shifts, 600kN.m with 2.023, 800kN.m with 1.892, 1000kN.m with 1.805, 2500kN.m with 1.767 and 3000kN.m with 1.740, plus single-cage builder's hoists 1t 75m with 1.958, double-cage builder's hoists 2 x 1t 100m with 2.408/2.523 and 2 x 1t 200m with 2.579/2.598/2.610 machine-shifts, and intercom machine-shifts - the machine-shift consumption decreases as eaves height rises, is an endogenous parameter of the line item, and counts as 'included'.
Step 3 - check the unit of measurement and pricing basis: vertical transport line items priced by gross floor area (m2) are a lump-sum basis, quantity following area and price including machine-shifts, so no further charge may be made from the number of plant machine-shifts; items priced by hired 'machine-days' (Hunan rule 2, and the SJG 181.5 basis excluding hire) are a hire-type basis, in which case machine-shifts or hired machine-days and the area-based vertical transport charge are mutually exclusive - keeping both is duplication. When a scheme change alters the number or model of plant, the correct treatment is to adjust the machine-shift content of the line item in proportion as the quota provides, or to adjust the crane model per the construction method statement (Jiangsu clauses 4 and 10), not to list extra machine-shifts.
Applicable boundaries
- This card settles the duplication judgment between 'vertical transport preliminaries' and 'machine-shift rates of major vertical transport plant'; it does not settle contract questions such as plant standing time charges, hire settlement prices or prolongation costs for delay.
- The inclusion and exclusion boundaries, units and machine-shift content bases of provincial consumption quotas are not uniform (building works mostly include machine-shifts on a lump-sum basis per gross floor area; municipal works and some provinces use machine-shift consumption bases that exclude hire), and must be judged from the current quota of the discipline and region of the project - clauses must not be applied across provinces.
- 'No duplication' presupposes that the vertical transport item has been charged normally under the BOQ and the quota; if it was priced at zero or not listed at tender, whether it can be recovered at final account is a question of the lump-sum effect of a preliminary item priced at zero, governed by other rules.
- Where eaves height or storey count exceeds the calibration range of the quota line items (Hunan above 150m, Jiangsu beyond the line-item calibration), calculation follows the actual construction scheme; estimating machine-shifts from the scheme is then allowed and is not the 'extra machine-shift' duplication.
Further reading
- GB/T 50854-2024 'Standard for measurement of building and decoration works', Appendix R, clauses R.1.1 and R.2.3 and Table R.1.1 (preliminary items, code 011601) - focus on checking the boundary of the work-content columns between 'vertical transport' and 'other large plant mobilisation and demobilisation with erection and dismantling'.
- GB 50854-2013, Appendix S, Table S.3 (vertical transport, code 011703) - the old coding and measurement basis for contrast; note this edition is superseded by GB/T 50854-2024 and 011703 is no longer used for new projects.
- Jiangsu Province consumption quota for building and decoration works (2026 edition), vertical transport works chapter, 'Notes' clauses 1, 4, 7 and 8, and the shared tower crane coefficient and integral connected basement clauses (chapter numbers per the quota contents).
- Hunan Province consumption standard for building and decoration works (2025 edition), chapter 20, vertical transport works, 'Notes' 1 to 6, 'quantity take-off rules' 1 to 3, and the machine-shift quantity estimation table.
- Shaanxi newly compiled consumption quota (consultation draft), line items 17-69 to 17-74 for 'tower crane construction above 3.20m (6 storeys)' (machine-shift content table - hard evidence that plant is included).
- SJG 181.5-2024 Consumption standard for municipal works, volume 5, water treatment works, clause 3.1.16 (the hire-type exclusion basis, for contrast).
- Duration basis: 'Duration quota for construction and installation works' TY01-89-2016 (the calibration basis for machine-shift quantity estimation).
Keywords
- 垂直运输
- 垂直运输费
- preliminary items
- 塔吊台班
- builder's hoist
- double counting
- 011703
- 011601
- 大型机械进出场及安拆