Rules for handling contract price adjustment for cost fluctuation in final account review and construction cost expert assessment: routing by contract type, price-dating principles for delay periods, the exception for government-priced materials, and the eight categories of costs not adjusted for changes in costs listed in GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.7.6
Final account review and expert assessment proceed on two levels. (i) Routing by contract type: for lump-sum contracts, unless otherwise agreed, cost fluctuation is generally not adjusted, and a contractor claiming adjustment for change of circumstances or prolonged duration must proceed by claim; for unit-rate contracts the agreement prevails, and absent or unclear agreement the matter is resolved by reference to national, local or sector provisions, with labour, materials and plant outside the contractually adjustable scope not adjustable. Price-dating during delay: where the delay is not attributable to the contractor, the higher of the prices at the planned and actual progress dates applies; where attributable to the contractor, the lower applies; concurrent delay is shared by sequence and responsibility. (ii) Hard constraint on the scope of adjustment: GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.7.6 lists eight categories of costs not adjusted for changes in costs (construction consumables, small and medium tools, preliminaries, plant and small tools costs other than fuel and power, material costs of items outside the agreed adjustable list, changes beyond the agreed scope or band, overheads and profit, and costs arising from the contractor's own causes); where the contract sets no band or sets it unclearly, fluctuation beyond 5% may be adjusted per Annex A (8.7.2), and abnormal movements of other materials outside the agreed adjustable scope may be handled by equitable risk allocation, by negotiation or by adjustment to actual costs (8.7.3, 3.3.6).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第3.3.6条、第8.7.2条、第8.7.3条、第8.7.6条
- GB/T 51262-2017 · Code for Construction Cost Appraisal 第5.6.2条
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023 · Work Guideline for Settlement Audit of Construction Works 第3.1.7条
- 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第十九条
Topic positioning
Rules for determining disputes over 'price adjustment for cost fluctuation' at the final account review and construction cost expert assessment stages, and which costs are not adjusted for changes in costs. It applies where the contract does not clearly provide an adjustment method, or the parties dispute the scope or band of adjustment, as the basis on which reviewers / expert assessors fix the treatment.
Core conclusions
I. Final account review basis (T/ZBD 100.5-2023, clause 3.1.7)
- Routing by contract type: 'For a lump-sum contract, unless otherwise agreed in the contract, cost fluctuation is generally not adjusted; where the contractor claims adjustment on grounds such as change of circumstances or prolonged duration, it should be handled as a claim. For a unit-rate contract, the contract usually provides an adjustment method for fluctuation beyond the risk range; where the contract clearly provides it, the agreement prevails; where the contract does not provide it or provides it unclearly, it may be handled by reference to the relevant national provisions or the provisions, rules and standards of the place where the works are located or the industry.'
- Scope of adjustment: only the labour, materials and construction plant that are adjustable under the risk-range clause agreed in the contract are adjusted; 'materials not within the range may not be adjusted'.
- Price-dating for periods of delay: (i) where the delay is due to a cause not attributable to the contractor, the price of the works after the planned progress date adopts the higher of the prices at the planned progress date and the actual progress date; (ii) where the delay is due to the contractor, the lower of the two applies; (iii) for concurrent delay, the burden is shared reasonably according to the sequence of and responsibility for the delays.
- Price base period: normally the base date agreed in the contract; absent agreement, the base period of the ceiling price in the tender documents applies, or 28 days before the tender submission deadline.
- Adjustment principle: note whether the contract adjusts 'in real time at the prices at the time of occurrence' or 'at the average price over the duration'; absent clear agreement, the employer and the contractor should align on the adjustment principle before adjusting; 'when adjusting prices, note that only the costs of the labour or material price changes, plus the corresponding taxes and duties, are taken; other costs should not be adjusted'.
- Adjustment methods: employer-supplied (free-issue) materials are adjusted according to the actual change and, where included in the contract price with only taxes and duties taken, are deducted; labour and material unit rates follow the contract, absent clear agreement the rules of the construction administration authority, and where the contract provides no adjustment but during performance the limits set by the construction administration authority are exceeded, the excess is adjusted and stated in the review report; construction plant unit rates are generally not adjusted unless expressly agreed in the contract; either the direct price adjustment method or the index-based (formula) adjustment method may be used.
II. Expert assessment basis (GB/T 51262-2017, clause 5.6.2)
Where the parties dispute the adjustment of the contract price for cost fluctuation, the expert assessor assesses per the following provisions:
- Where the contract provides the pricing risk range and band, assess per the contract; where the contract provides that cost fluctuation is adjustable but does not provide the risk range and band, refer the matter to the commissioning party to decide and assess per the relevant provisions of the current national pricing standard, except where the price index method has already been applied;
- Where the contract provides that cost fluctuation is not adjustable, materials subject to government-set pricing or government guidance pricing are still assessed per the relevant laws (water, electricity, fuel and certain other raw materials in China remain under government-set or guidance pricing, and their price adjustments follow the implementation rules for government-set / guidance prices; the Contract Law rules cited by this clause have been carried over by the contract part of the Civil Code, and the name of the law should be updated when citing).
III. Scope of costs not adjusted for changes in costs (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.7.6, unless otherwise agreed in the contract)
- Construction consumables;
- Small and medium tools;
- Preliminaries;
- Plant and small tools costs other than the fuel and power costs of construction plant whose prices are adjusted under clauses 8.7.1 to 8.7.4;
- Material costs of items that are not contractually agreed price-adjustment items, other than the abnormal price movements provided in clause 8.7.3;
- Price changes beyond the price-adjustment scope and band agreed in the contract, or price changes of adjustable items whose fluctuation does not exceed the bands for labour costs, material costs and the fuel and power costs of construction plant provided in clause 8.7.2;
- Overheads and profit;
- Costs arising from the contractor's own causes.
IV. Two fallback channels
- Clause 8.7.2: where the market prices of the labour costs, material costs and fuel and power costs of construction plant agreed in the contract as adjustable fluctuate beyond the band agreed in the contract, and the contract sets no band or provides it unclearly, where the market price fluctuation exceeds 5%, the contract price may be adjusted by one of the methods in Annex A; where the fluctuation does not exceed the band borne by the contractor, the prices of the BOQ items of the works in the relevant adjustment period may be left unadjusted.
- Clause 8.7.3: where the market price of other material costs outside the contractually agreed adjustment scope moves abnormally, and this is a major change that the employer and the contractor could not foresee at contract conclusion and continued performance is obviously unfair to the adversely affected party, the two sides may, under the principle of equitable risk allocation, negotiate the contractual risk band or the cost-sharing ratio, bearing the relevant increase (decrease) in price differential or adjusting the contract price to the actual costs.
- Clause 3.3.6: for BOQ items for which the contract does not provide price adjustment for changes in costs, where market prices move abnormally beyond the band agreed in the contract, or the contract sets no fluctuation band but market prices move abnormally in a way that an experienced contractor could not foresee, the two sides may, per clause 3.3.5, adjust the prices of the BOQ items affected by the abnormally moved prices, with the costs reasonably shared by the two sides.
Scope of application
- The preface to clause 8.7.6 is 'unless otherwise agreed in the contract' - where the contract has a clear price-adjustment agreement, the agreement governs; the 5% in clause 8.7.2 applies only where the contract sets no band or provides it unclearly; where a band is agreed (e.g. 3%), the agreement governs.
- The review guideline (T/ZBD 100.5-2023) is an industry association standard, a methodological reference and not a basis of adjudication; assessment conclusions remain doubly constrained by the pricing standard and the contract.
- At the judicial level, 'whether a fixed-price contract may be adjusted for a major rise in material prices' is a separate layer of assessment (separate agreement plus the elements of change of circumstances); the adjustment rules of the pricing standard cannot substitute for that judicial review.
- This card does not address whether a price itself is reasonable (the handling of deviation between published price information and market price is governed by other rules).
Further reading
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023 Work Guideline for Final Account Review of Construction Works, clause 3.1.7 (routing of lump-sum / unit-rate contracts, price-dating in delay, base period, adjustment principles and adjustment methods)
- GB/T 51262-2017 Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment, clause 5.6.2 (assessment rules for cost fluctuation adjustment disputes; exception for government-priced materials)
- GB/T 50500-2024 Pricing Standard for Bill of Quantities of Construction Works, clause 8.7.2 (the 5% band and the Annex A methods), clause 8.7.3 (risk sharing for abnormal movements of other materials), clause 8.7.6 (eight categories of costs not adjusted), clause 3.3.6 (sharing of abnormal movements for items with no agreed adjustment)
- Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 19 (where the pricing standard or pricing method is agreed, the agreement prevails)