Selecting between the two methods of contract price adjustment for changes in costs: comparison of applicable conditions, clause-by-clause contrast and same-contract mixing boundaries of the Appendix A.1 index-based adjustment and the Appendix A.2 adjustment based on published price information under GB/T 50500-2024
The two methods share an identical adjustable scope, base time point and trigger threshold (only labour cost, key material cost and the fuel and power cost of construction plant are adjustable; the base time point is 28 days before the tender deadline; where the contract sets no band or sets it unclearly, fluctuations beyond 5% are adjustable; the differential carries VAT only, never overheads or profit). The difference lies only in the price variable. A.1, index-based (formula) adjustment, takes the VAT-exclusive contract price P0 as the base and weights the fixed weight A and the variable weights B1...Bn of each adjustable factor by the ratio 'current index / base index' - the index source is agreed in the contract, the agreed fluctuation band is folded into the base price index, and where an index is missing the previous measurement period's index may be used provisionally. A.2, adjustment based on published price information, takes the adjustable factor quantity Q as the base and computes the money price differential between the base price C0 and the measurement-period market price Ci less the risk band coefficient r; the base price and the market price are each chosen from three sources (market price used in setting the tender price ceiling / published price information of the cost management agency / tender-winning prices published by the trading centre), whether the band is exceeded is determined by scenarios of the tender price against the base price, and under the purchase-price route the contractor must submit quantity and unit price to the employer for checking before purchase (no reply in time is deemed approval). The standard itself has no dedicated 'applicable conditions' clause, only 'one of the methods of Appendix A'; the choice is first a matter for the contract; where one contract assigns different methods to different adjustable factors, they must be entered separately in Table G.2.1-1 (published price information method) / Table G.2.1-2 (index method), without double counting the same differential.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第 3.3.5 条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第 8.7.1 条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第 8.7.2 条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第 8.7.3 条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第 8.7.4 条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第 8.7.6 条
- GB/T 50500-2024 App. A.1(A.1.1~A.1.6)价格指数调差法
- GB/T 50500-2024 App. A.2(A.2.1~A.2.5)价格信息调差法
- GB/T 50500-2024 App. G Table G.2.1-1、Table G.2.1-2
Topic positioning
Based on GB/T 50500-2024 'China national pricing standard for BOQ', Appendix A and Sections 3.3 and 8.7, this card compares the applicable conditions, clause yardsticks and same-contract mixing boundaries of the index-based (formula) adjustment method (Appendix A.1, A.1.1-A.1.6) and the adjustment method based on published price information (Appendix A.2, A.2.1-A.2.5), for drafting contract price-adjustment clauses, stating the adjustment method in tender documents, and method selection when reviewing adjustment proposals.
Core conclusions
I. First calibrate terms and positioning. The formal standard term for the 'price index adjustment method' is index-based adjustment (Appendix A.1); 'adjusting the price differential by cost information' is the old 2013 name, formally replaced in the 2024 edition by adjustment based on published price information (Appendix A.2).
The standard clauses themselves contain no dedicated 'applicable conditions' clause, only a choice between the two methods: Clause 3.3.5 item 1 'Where the contract price is affected by fluctuations in labour and key material prices, the employer and the contractor shall adjust the contract price by one of the methods of Appendix A of this standard'; Clause 8.7.2 item 2 'Amounts of billed items for the works of the relevant adjustment period may be adjusted by the index-based adjustment method or the method based on published price information.' Selection is first governed by the contractual agreement (statutory first, agreed terms prevail).
II. The common preconditions of the two methods are entirely identical; the difference is not 'whether adjustable' but 'which price variable is used and on what yardstick the differential is computed':
- The adjustable scope is limited to labour cost, material cost, and the fuel and power cost within construction plant and small tools cost in the component-works BOQ (Clause 8.7.1); where fuel and power cost is allowed to adjust for fuel price fluctuation, it may follow the key-material adjustment method (Clause 3.3.5 item 3).
- The scope of price-adjustable key materials must be clarified by both parties and Table G.2.1-1 or Table G.2.1-2 completed per Appendix G.2 as a contract annex (Clause 3.3.5 item 2).
- The trigger is market price fluctuation beyond the contractually agreed band; where the contract sets no band or sets it unclearly, only fluctuations beyond 5% may be adjusted by one of the Appendix A methods (Clause 8.7.2 item 1); below that, no adjustment.
- The differential carries VAT but not overheads or profit - the risk of overheads and profit is allowed for by tenderers as risk money in their tenders (Clause 3.3.5 item 4).
- Common exclusions (Clause 8.7.6): construction consumables, small and medium tools, preliminaries, construction plant and small tools cost other than fuel and power, material cost of items outside the contractually agreed adjustment scope, price changes beyond scope or band, overheads and profit, and costs arising from the contractor's own fault shall not, on account of changes in costs, adjust the contract price or the rates.
- On delay the price direction follows responsibility: employer-caused delay takes the higher of the prices at the planned and actual progress dates, contractor-caused delay the lower; delay caused by neither party is adjusted per Clause 8.7.2 (Clause 8.7.4).
III. Clause comparison (clause numbers aligned)
| Dimension | A.1 index-based adjustment | A.2 adjustment based on published price information |
|---|---|---|
| Computation base | Aggregate contract-price basis: P0 = the VAT-exclusive contract amount the contractor is entitled to for the agreed measurement period; excluding price adjustment, the deduction and payment of retention money, and the payment and recovery of prepayment; variations and other amounts already priced at current prices are excluded, but amounts for BOQ errors and omissions and for variations and other amounts computed at tendered labour, material and plant unit rates shall be included (A.1.1) | Item-by-item quantity basis: delta P is the current adjustment amount computed for the measurement period, delta C the differential of the adjustable factor, Q the quantity of the adjustable factor; where another method sets the quantities, it must be specified in the tender documents and the particular conditions of the contract (A.2.1) |
| Price variable | Price indices of each adjustable factor: Ft current price index, F0 base price index; with the fixed weight A and the variable weights B1...Bn (variable weights as shares of the VAT-exclusive contract price), adjusting by weighting the ratio 'current index / base index' (A.1.1) | Money prices: the differential between the base price C0 and the measurement-period market price Ci (A.2.1) |
| Determination of price source | 'The source or the method of determining the price indices shall be agreed by the employer and the contractor in the contract', together with the adjustment rules for all-in unit rates and how their price indices are determined (A.1.1) | C0 three options: (1) the market price used by the employer in setting the tender price ceiling; (2) the quarterly (monthly) published price information of the construction cost management agency; (3) tender-winning prices for similar projects under the same conditions within the previous month published by the trading centre of the project locality. Ci three options: (1) the market price of the measurement period confirmed by the employer and the contractor; (2) current quarterly (monthly) published price information; (3) trading-centre tender-winning prices for similar works under the same conditions within the previous month. Each must represent the market price level of the corresponding time point; the tenderer shall state in the tender documents the price source, issuing agency and specific quarter (month) of C0 (A.2.1) |
| Base time point | The base price index = the index at the contract base date: 28 days before the tender deadline for tendered works, 28 days before contract signing for non-tendered works; the tenderer shall state it in the tender documents (A.1.6) | The base price C0 is likewise the market price 28 days before the tender deadline (28 days before contract signing for non-tendered works) (A.2.1) |
| Risk (fluctuation) band treatment | Folded into the index: where a price fluctuation band is contractually allowed, the base price index accounts for that band factor (A.1.1) | Explicit coefficient r: r positive when delta C > 0, negative when delta C < 0; whether the band is exceeded is determined under A.2.4 in three scenarios (A.2.1, A.2.4) |
| Tender price vs base price | No such rule (weighted aggregate adjustment, no distinction by tendered rate level) | A.2.4 sets three scenarios: (1) tendered rate below the base price - a rise is tested against the base price, or a fall against the tender price, for exceeding the risk band, the excess adjusting on fact; (2) tendered rate above the base price - a fall tested against the base price, or a rise against the tender price, the excess adjusting on fact; (3) tendered rate equal to the base price - both rise and fall tested against the base price, the excess adjusting on fact |
| Weights / missing data | Where variations make the originally agreed contract weights unreasonable, the employer and the contractor adjust them by agreement (A.1.3); where the variable weights are not agreed, the variable weights of each adjustable factor may take those of the tender price ceiling (A.1.4) | No concept of weights |
| Current price missing | Where no current price index exists, the index of the previous measurement period may be used provisionally and trued up in later payments at the actual index (A.1.2) | Where market price information for the measurement period is absent or the parties differ widely, the published price information of the cost management agency may be used provisionally and later adjusted to the actual market price information (A.2.2); where the employer-verified purchase price is used, the contractor submits quantity and unit price before purchase, the employer's failure to reply within the agreed period is deemed approval, and batch purchases may be averaged by weights (A.2.5) |
| Multiple prices within a period | The arithmetic mean of the price indices within the measurement period, the weighted mean of the indices and the corresponding completed quantities, or the index over the main-consumption construction period may be used; the method or its order of priority is agreed by the parties (A.1.5) | Likewise the arithmetic mean of market prices within the period, the weighted mean with the corresponding completed quantities, or the market price over the main-consumption period; method and order of priority agreed by the parties (A.2.3) |
| Accompanying tables | Table G.2.1-2, schedule 2 of price-adjustable key materials provided by the contractor (name, specification and model, base price index filled by the tenderer; where labour also adjusts by the index method, the tenderer fills the 'name' column) (G.2.1) | Table G.2.1-1, schedule 1 of price-adjustable key materials provided by the contractor (the tenderer fills serial number, name, specification, model, unit, base price, risk band; tenderers fill their tender prices) (G.2.1) |
IV. Selection criteria (an engineering reading inferred from the clause elements, not clause wording)
| Factor | Favours A.1 index-based adjustment | Favours A.2 adjustment based on published price information |
|---|---|---|
| Material standardisation | Few varieties, highly standardised bulk materials with stable price index series (steel, cement, concrete and similar key materials) | Non-standard, decorative and equipment materials with many specifications and models, each with its own base price and tender price |
| Duration | Long duration, many measurement periods, aggregate weighted adjustment on lump-sum-type contracts | Shorter duration or item-by-item settlement per measurement period on actual purchase quantities |
| Availability of indices / published prices | Locally published, continuously obtainable price indices (and weights obtainable from the tender price ceiling) | The cost management agency publishes price information periodically, and base and current prices are obtainable from the same source |
| Procurement complexity | Unified procurement channels, no batch-by-batch price confirmation | Batch procurement, purchase-price confirmation needed (A.2.5 procedure complete) or item-by-item anti-arbitrage on the tender-price-to-base-price relation (A.2.4) |
| Coverage of adjustable factors | Labour cost, multi-factor aggregate adjustment (weights naturally fit multiple factors) | Price differential accounting for a single material or a few materials |
V. Boundaries of mixing the two methods in one contract
- At clause level: Clause 3.3.5 item 1 reads 'one of the methods of Appendix A', Appendix G provides separately Table G.2.1-1 (published price information method) and Table G.2.1-2 (index method), and the notes to G.2.1 add that where 'labour also adjusts by the index-based adjustment method' the tenderer fills the column - so adjustable factors and methods may be assigned separately; but the standard sets no express mixing rule, and in practice any mix (key materials by the index method, auxiliaries or individual materials by the published price information method) must be anchored in the contractual agreement.
- Operational requirements for mixing (engineering reading): (1) the contract (weight schedule in the appendix to the letter of tender / price index and weight schedule) must name the method for each adjustable factor and the exact source, issuing agency and quarter (month) of its price index or price information; (2) Tables G.2.1-1 and G.2.1-2 are completed separately as contract annexes, and the materials listed in the two tables must not overlap; (3) each adjustable factor uses one method only within one adjustment period - no double counting of the same differential; (4) the base time point of both methods must be unified at 28 days before the tender deadline (28 days before contract signing for non-tendered works), so that one period's differential never has two bases; (5) mixed or not, the differential carries VAT only, never overheads or profit.
- No mixing: where the contract has expressly agreed a single method with no revision mechanism, neither party may unilaterally switch to the other method at settlement; costs within the Clause 8.7.6 exclusions (preliminaries, construction consumables, material cost of non-adjustment items, etc.) may not enter adjustment under either method.
Applicable boundaries
- Applies to adjustment of construction contract prices for changes in costs under the GB/T 50500-2024 system: where the contract has agreed the method, scope, band, price source and adjustment period, that agreement governs; where nothing is agreed or the agreement is unclear, this standard applies (especially the 5% fallback band).
- The 'selection table' above is an engineering reading inferred from the clause requirements of the two methods and is not an applicable-conditions clause of the standard text; do not cite it as 'the standard requires material X to use method Y'.
- The P0 basis of the index-based method must follow A.1.1 strictly (VAT-exclusive, excluding price adjustment, ignoring retention money and prepayment, excluding variations already priced at current prices, but including BOQ errors and omissions and variations computed at tendered labour, material and plant unit rates); a wrong basis systematically inflates or deflates the differential.
- In the published price information method the base price and the measurement-period price must be of the same basis, the same source and representative of the same time point; comparisons across sources (base price from published price information, market price from a purchase invoice) do not stand.
- Where other material cost outside the contractually agreed adjustment scope moves abnormally, was unforeseeable at contracting, and would render continued performance obviously unfair to one party, Clause 8.7.3 applies: negotiate the risk band or the cost-sharing ratio on the principle of equitable risk allocation and adjust on fact - the two formula methods do not apply.
- lump-sum contracts with a fixed price handle cost fluctuation per their own contract terms; this card does not apply of itself.
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 'China national pricing standard for BOQ': Clause 3.3.5 (adjustment method, scope of adjustable key materials, fuel and power cost, VAT rule), Clause 8.7.1 (basic path of differential computation), Clause 8.7.2 (5% band and choice of the two methods), Clause 8.7.3 (negotiation on abnormal fluctuation), Clause 8.7.4 (price direction on extended duration), Clause 8.7.6 (list of non-adjustable costs).
- Appendix A.1: A.1.1 (formula, weights and base price index), A.1.2 (provisional use of the previous period's index), A.1.3 (agreed adjustment of weights after variations), A.1.4 (variable weights unset - take those of the tender price ceiling), A.1.5 (multiple index values within a period), A.1.6 (contract base date, 28 days).
- Appendix A.2: A.2.1 (formula, sources of C0 / Ci, sign of r), A.2.2 (provisional use of published price information), A.2.3 (multiple price values within a period), A.2.4 (three scenarios of tender price against base price), A.2.5 (purchase-price confirmation and deemed approval on late reply).
- Appendix G Tables G.2.1-1 and G.2.1-2 and the table notes (division of filling duties for price-adjustable key materials under the two methods).
- The 2013 edition 'Pricing specification for BOQ of construction works' GB 50500-2013 has been replaced by GB/T 50500-2024 (the 2024 edition is a recommended national standard); the old name 'adjusting the price differential by cost information' corresponds to the current 'adjustment based on published price information' - check the edition before citing clause numbers and never mix 2013 clause numbers.
Keywords
- index-based (formula) adjustment
- adjustment based on published price information
- GB/T 50500-2024
- Appendix A
- 变值权重
- 风险幅度系数
- schedule of price-adjustable key materials
- 物价变化合同价格调整
- 调价方法选型