Appendix A price adjustment (for fluctuation) methods for changes in costs, GB 50500-2013 vs GB/T 50500-2024: weighting coefficient basis and adjustment threshold differences
The two editions share the same formula skeleton in Appendix A (index-based (formula) adjustment dP = P0[A + sum BiFit/Fi0 - 1]; adjustment based on published price information adjusts the portion beyond the risk band (no-adjustment tolerance, e.g. ±5%) at actual values); differences lie in the basis and mechanisms: (1) weighting — 2013 variable weights are 'proportions of the total tender price in the tender letter' (including VAT), 2024 uses 'weights of the contract price excluding VAT' (separation of net price and VAT), and 2024 adds A.1.4 fallback 'where variable weights are not agreed, the corresponding weights of the tender price ceiling may be used' and A.1.1 merges the fluctuation range into the base price index F0; (2) thresholds — both editions' fallback is 5% (beyond which actual-value adjustment applies; 2013 clause 9.8.2, 2024 clause 8.7.2), and 2024 adds the sign rule for the r risk band coefficient, defines the base price (reference price for adjustment) as the market price 28 days before the tender deadline (= FIDIC Base Date) (28 days before contract signing for non-tendered works), and the 8.7.6 list of items not subject to price adjustment. GB 50500-2013 was mandatory (replaced); 2024 is recommended national standard GB/T.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准(App. A、第8.7节、App. G)
- GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范(App. A、第9.8节)
Topic Positioning
Comparing Appendix A 'contract price adjustment (for fluctuation) methods for changes in costs' of GB 50500-2013 (mandatory, replaced) and GB/T 50500-2024 (China national pricing standard for BOQ, recommended, current) on weighting coefficient basis and adjustment thresholds — for edition transition, drafting contract price adjustment clauses, and final account review. Both editions' Appendix A contain A.1 (index-based (formula) adjustment) and A.2 (cost information / published price information differential adjustment method) with identical formula skeletons; differences concentrate in the basis and refined mechanisms.
Core Conclusions
1. Weighting coefficients (A.1 index-based (formula) adjustment)
- Variable weight Bi basis: 2013 — 'the variable weight of each adjustable factor (i.e., the weight of the adjustable portion), being its proportion of the total tender price in the tender letter' (tender total including value added tax (VAT)); 2024 — 'the weight of each adjustable factor's variable portion in the contract price excluding VAT' (separation of net price and VAT).
- P0 calculation base: 2013 — 'the amount for completed quantities due to the contractor in the agreed payment certificate', excluding price adjustments, retention money withholding/payment, prepayment payment/recovery, and variations already priced at current prices; 2024 — 'the contract price amount excluding value added tax (VAT) due to the contractor in the agreed measurement period', likewise excluding adjustments, retention money, prepayments, and current-priced variations, but adding 'errors and omissions in the BOQ and variations and other amounts priced at the labour, material and plant unit prices of the winning tender price shall be included'.
- Unagreed-weight fallback: 2013 has none; 2024 adds A.1.4 'where variable weights are not agreed, the corresponding weights of the tender price ceiling may be used'.
- Base price index F0: 2013 — 'the price index of each adjustable factor at the base date'; 2024 A.1.1 adds 'where the contract allows a price fluctuation range, the base price index shall consider this fluctuation range coefficient' — the fluctuation range is merged into F0 rather than acting as a separate threshold.
- Agreement carrier: 2013 — price index and weight table in the tender letter appendix (Appendix L.3 Table 22); 2024 — the tender letter table plus Appendix G Table G.2.1-2 (schedule of price-adjustable key materials II); the adjustable factors, fixed/variable weights, and base index sources are scoped by the employer, and objecting tenderers must seek clarification before tendering.
Note: the adjustment based on published price information (A.2) has no valuation-formula weights; the 2024 A.2 phrase 'batch purchases may take the weighted average' refers to purchase-lot weighted averaging, distinct from the Bi weights of the index-based method — do not confuse.
2. Adjustment thresholds (risk band)
- Fallback threshold: 2013 9.8.2 — 'where there is no agreement and unit prices of materials/engineering equipment change by more than 5%, the portion beyond shall be adjusted per Appendix A'; 2024 8.7.2 — 'where the contract does not specify a risk band or the agreement is unclear, when market price fluctuations exceed 5%, the contract price may be adjusted by one of the methods of Appendix A', adding that 'where fluctuations do not exceed the contractor-borne risk band agreed in the contract, the prices of billed (BOQ) items in that period need not be adjusted'. Both fallbacks are 5% with beyond-portion actual adjustment; 2024 stresses that the contractual agreement takes precedence.
- Calculation base beyond the risk band: 2013 A.2.3 three scenarios — tender price below the base unit price (rise computed from base price, fall from tender price), above base price (fall from base price, rise from tender price), equal (both from base price), with the portion beyond the agreed risk band adjusted at actual values; 2024 A.2.1/A.2.4 keeps the three scenarios and adds the sign rule 'when dC > 0, r is positive; when dC < 0, r is negative'.
- Base price (reference price for adjustment) C0 definition: 2013 gives no time anchor (set via Appendix L.2 Table 21); 2024 defines it as 'the market price level 28 days before the tender deadline (= FIDIC Base Date) (for non-tendered works, 28 days before contract signing)', with permissible sources being the market prices used by the employer for the tender price ceiling, the published price information (government guidance prices) for the current quarter/month issued by cost management agencies, or tender prices/winning tender prices of similar projects published by trading centres within the previous month; tender documents must specify the price source, publishing body, and quarter/month.
- Non-adjustable scope: 2024 adds the 8.7.6 list (construction consumables, small and medium-sized tool costs, preliminaries, other plant costs, changes beyond the agreed adjustment scope, management fee and profit); 2013 only had 9.8.4 (employer-supplied materials not subject to 9.8.1/9.8.2).
- Delay handling: 2013 9.8.3 two scenarios (non-contractor cause takes the higher value; contractor cause the lower); 2024 8.7.4 three scenarios, adding cause attributable to neither party adjusted per 8.7.2.
Key points: the numeric mechanism (fixed A + variable Bi) is identical; the change is basis — 2013 by proportion of the tender total including VAT, 2024 by weights based on the contract price excluding VAT, with the added weight fallback (A.1.4) and fluctuation-range-into-F0 treatment (A.1.1); the threshold fallback is 5% in both, with 2024 refining the base price time anchor, r sign rule, and list of items not subject to price adjustment.
Applicable Boundaries
- Applies to adjusting labour, materials (engineering equipment), and plant and small tools cost (fuel and power) for changes in costs in employer-contractor contract prices under pricing on a bill of quantities basis.
- GB 50500-2013 (mandatory) is replaced by GB/T 50500-2024 (recommended); current projects follow 2024, with 2013 used only for legacy contract settlement and edition comparison.
- Where the contract clearly agrees adjustable material scope, risk band, base price source, and quantities subject to price adjustment rules, agreed terms prevail; this card's differences mainly serve fallback application when unspecified or unclear, and identifying the basis under each edition.
- A.1 requires the tender letter's index and weight table; A.2 requires base prices and market prices for the measurement period; the method choice is set by tender documents/contract, and the two risk band mechanisms (r versus risk band) must not be mixed.
Further Reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 Appendix A: A.1.1 (index formula, P0 basis, F0 fluctuation range treatment), A.1.4 (weight fallback), A.2.1 (published price information method formula, C0 definition and sources), A.2.4 (tender price versus base price cross rules), A.2.5 (batch weighted average); 8.7.2 (5% fallback), 8.7.4 (three delay scenarios), 8.7.6 (list of items not subject to price adjustment); Appendix G Tables G.2.1-1/G.2.1-2.
- GB 50500-2013 Appendix A: A.1.1 (index formula), A.2.1 (labour and plant adjusted per published price information), A.2.3 (three scenarios, beyond-risk-band actual adjustment); 9.8.2 (5% fallback), 9.8.3 (two delay scenarios), 9.8.4 (employer-supplied materials excluded).