Routes for claiming final account quantities of concealed works where no measurement records exist: the pre-concealment measurement confirmation procedure, who bears the exposure costs after covering without notice, the ranking of supplementary evidence, the requirements for retrospectively certified quantity sheets, and the interface with measurement from drawings
The absence of measurement records does not mean quantities cannot be claimed, but the claim route shifts from 'measurement certified on as-built facts at the time' to 'measurement re-proven from facts of completion plus a chain of evidence', with two adverse consequences: (1) where the works were covered without notice, the costs of drilling probes or uncovering for inspection and of reinstatement are always borne by the contractor and are not shifted by conforming quality (GF-2017-0201 clause 5.3.4); (2) the burden of proof is heavier - where there is no signed certification, the drawings cannot reflect the work and no site inspection is possible, the expert assessment refuses measurement as an 'item not susceptible to assessment' (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.3.6 item 5). On the measurement confirmation procedure, failure to check within the time limit triggers deemed approval (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 7.1.5 and 7.1.6), and measurement results signed and confirmed by both parties become the basis for the final account (clause 7.1.8), but such approval 'shall not serve as the basis for deeming the relevant works handed over as conforming'; quantities ultimately return to reconstruction from design-drawing dimensions plus variation instructions plus certified site records plus measurement rules (clause 7.2.1).
Applicable Codes
- GF-2017-0201 建设工程施工合同(示范文本)第4.4款、第5.3款(5.3.1~5.3.4)、第5.4款、第5.5款
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第7.1.5、7.1.6、7.1.8、7.2.1、12.2.1条
- GB/T 50319-2013 建设工程监理规范 第5.2.14条及Table B.0.7、Table B.0.8
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 建设工程造价鉴定作业指引 第4.3.6条
- GB/T 51262-2017 建设工程造价鉴定规范 第5.9.1、5.9.2条
- 建设工程质量管理条例(2017修订)第三十条
- 中华人民共和国合同法 第二百七十八条(现由民法典第七百九十八条承继)
Topic positioning
Concealed works (piles, rebar, waterproofing, embedded pipework, foundations and the like) leave nothing on site to measure once covered; where no measurement records certified by the supervising engineer were produced during construction, can the contractor claim final account quantities, and by what route? This card gives: the procedural clauses, the consequence judgment for covering without notice, the ranking of provable supplementary evidence, the procedural requirements for retrospectively certified quantity sheets, and the interface with measurement from drawings or from actuals.
Core conclusion
1. First separate the two lines: acceptance (quality) is not measurement (quantity) A concealed works acceptance record proves that 'the part has been completed, the quality conforms and covering is permitted'; it is a precondition of measurement (completed, conforming work that should be measured), but the parts and dimensions on the record do not automatically equal final account quantities - quantities must still be computed on the line of 'design-drawing dimensions + variations + certified site records + measurement rules'. GB/T 50500-2024 clause 7.1.5 likewise states that where the employer fails to provide the checking result within the agreed time, the measurement results deemed accepted 'may serve as the basis for calculating the contract price but shall not serve as the basis for deeming the relevant works handed over as conforming'.
2. Procedural clauses on measurement confirmation before concealment
- Model text GF-2017-0201 clause 5.3 [Inspection of concealed works]
- 5.3.1 Contractor self-inspection: the contractor shall self-inspect the concealed parts of the works and confirm by self-inspection whether they are ready for covering.
- 5.3.2 Inspection procedure: unless the particular conditions provide otherwise, where the contractor confirms by self-inspection that a concealed part is ready for covering, it shall give the supervising engineer 48 hours' written notice before joint inspection, stating the content, time and place of the concealed-works inspection and attaching the self-inspection record and the necessary inspection data; 'only after the supervising engineer inspects and confirms that the quality meets the concealment requirements and signs the acceptance record may the contractor proceed to cover'. If the supervising engineer cannot inspect on time, it shall submit a written request for postponement to the contractor 24 hours before the inspection, the postponement not exceeding 48 hours; where this delays completion, the time for completion is extended. If the supervising engineer neither inspects on time nor requests postponement, the concealed works inspection is deemed passed and the contractor may complete the covering itself and send the corresponding record to the supervising engineer, which shall sign confirmation.
- 5.3.3 Re-inspection: after the contractor has covered a concealed part, the employer or the supervising engineer, doubting the quality, may require the contractor to drill probes or uncover for re-inspection; the contractor shall comply and re-cover and reinstate after inspection. Where inspection proves the quality meets the contract, the employer bears the costs thereby added and/or the delay and pays the contractor a reasonable profit; where it does not meet the contract, the contractor bears them.
- 5.3.4 Covering without permission: where the contractor covers a concealed part without notifying the supervising engineer to attend, the supervising engineer may instruct the contractor to drill probes or uncover for inspection; whether or not the concealed part is of conforming quality, the costs thereby added and/or the delay are borne by the contractor.
- Statute and administrative regulation level
- Contract Law article 278 [Acceptance of concealed works] (carried over unchanged as Civil Code article 798): 'Before concealing concealed works, the contractor shall notify the employer to inspect. If the employer does not inspect in time, the contractor may extend the construction period and claim compensation for losses from suspension, idle labour and plant and the like.' - the statute provides only the consequence of 'failure to inspect in time' (extension of time plus compensation for suspension and idle costs), not the forfeiture consequence of 'covering without notice'; the forfeiture and cost-bearing rules sit at contract and standard level.
- Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works, article 30: 'The construction entity must establish and improve its construction quality inspection system, manage processes strictly, and keep good quality inspection and records for concealed works. Before concealment, the construction entity shall notify the construction employer and the construction quality supervision agency.' The obligor is the construction entity; notice goes to the employer plus the quality supervision agency.
- Supervision code GB/T 50319-2013 clause 5.2.14: the project supervision body shall take the inspection filings for concealed works, inspection lots, sub-divisional and divisional works, sign certification when acceptance passes, refuse certification when it fails and require rectification and re-filing within a set time; where it doubts the quality of a concealed part it has agreed to cover, or discovers covering without permission, it shall require re-inspection by drilling, stripping or other means; the filing forms are Form B.0.7 (concealed works, inspection lots, sub-divisional works) and Form B.0.8 (divisional works). Cost basis: where inspection passes, the employer bears the costs added and/or the delay and pays a reasonable profit; where it fails, the construction entity bears them.
- Pricing standard (GB/T 50500-2024, current edition, superseding GB 50500-2013) measurement confirmation procedure
- Clause 7.1.5: the contractor shall submit the measurement results of the relevant works to the employer in writing for checking; the employer, on receipt, shall notify the contractor of the checking result in writing within the agreed time. If the employer fails to provide the checking result within the agreed time, the measurement results submitted by the contractor may be deemed accepted by the employer; unless the contract provides otherwise, those measurement results may serve as the basis for calculating the contract price but shall not serve as the basis for deeming the relevant works handed over as conforming.
- Clause 7.1.6: on receipt of the checking result the contractor shall confirm in writing within the agreed time, or submit written review comments with detailed calculation data; if the employer neither confirms nor notifies the review result in time, the review comments submitted by the contractor may be deemed accepted by the employer; if the contractor neither confirms nor submits review comments in time, the checked measurement results of the employer may be deemed accepted by the contractor, and unless the contract provides otherwise the checked measurement results of the employer may serve as the basis for calculating the contract price.
- Clause 7.1.8: measurement results signed and confirmed by the employer and the contractor shall serve as the basis for adjusting the contract price and for settling the works, except where the contract provides otherwise or both parties expressly limit them to the basis for progress payments or the measurement results are rough estimates.
- Clause 12.2.1: the employer and the contractor shall agree in the contract the scope of duties of their respective site management personnel; written documents signed by the site management personnel of both parties within their scope of duties are valid vouchers for pricing, unless other valid evidence or verified facts prove them false.
- Clause 7.2.1: the unit-rate priced BOQ items of the divisional and elemental works list under a re-measurable contract shall be re-measured from the as-built construction drawings provided by the employer and the variation instructions issued and confirmed, under the national and trade quantity take-off standards agreed in the contract and the supplementary calculation rules, and may serve as the basis for calculating the prices of the divisional and elemental list items.
- Fallback for disputes: model text clause 4.4 [Agreement or determination] - the chief supervising engineer shall try to reach agreement with the parties to the contract; failing agreement, it makes a careful and fair determination per the contract, notifies the employer and the contractor in writing with detailed grounds; absent objection the determination is executed, with objection the matter is handled under clause 20 [dispute resolution]; before the dispute is resolved the chief supervising engineer's determination is provisionally executed, after resolution the outcome prevails, and losses are borne by the responsible party.
3. Consequence judgment for concealment without notice (no measurement records)
- Right to verify by exposure: the supervising engineer or the employer may instruct drilling probes or uncovering for re-inspection, and the contractor shall comply and re-cover and reinstate after inspection (5.3.3).
- Cost bearing: in covering without permission, whether or not the concealed part is of conforming quality, the exposure, reinstatement, costs added and/or delay are always borne by the contractor (5.3.4); where notice was properly given and inspection passed, the costs and delay are borne by the employer with a reasonable profit (5.3.3).
- Notice given but the supervising engineer neither inspected on time nor requested postponement: the inspection is deemed passed and the contractor may cover the works itself and submit records - here the lack of measurement records is not the contractor's fault and it is a favourable fact when supplementing evidence.
4. Ranking of supplementary evidence (from strongest to weakest)
| Rank | Evidence | Key points of probative force |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Concealed works acceptance record (with self-inspection record, inspection data, supervising engineer's signed confirmation) | Statutory acceptance voucher; proves 'completed, conforming, covering permitted' plus the part, content and time; the precondition evidence for measurement; filing forms per GB/T 50319-2013 Forms B.0.7/B.0.8 carry stronger formal force |
| 2 | Imagery taken before covering (with dimensional references, verifiable time and place) | Directly reflects the geometry and workmanship actually executed; the most direct quantity supplement when the drawings cannot reflect it; must be locatable to a specific part and time |
| 3 | Supervision logs, material delivery records, test and inspection reports, construction logs and process filing registers | Corroborate the facts of completion and the inputs (e.g. concrete volume, tonnage of rebar delivered) and allow quantities to be back-derived, but need mutual corroboration with other evidence |
| 4 | Witness statements (accounts by construction and supervision personnel) | Weakest standing alone; must be paired with the above documents and imagery; without any documentary support they can hardly carry a measurement conclusion alone |
| Two further 'upgrade' rules: (1) written documents signed by the site management personnel of both parties within their scope of duties are themselves valid pricing vouchers (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 12.2.1), unless other valid evidence proves them false; (2) where the parties dispute unit-rate contract quantities and no drawings exist or the drawings cannot reflect the work, the expert assessment proceeds by ladder - valid signed certification by both parties -> certification signed by one party with the supervising engineer (or the designer) without effective rebuttal evidence from the other -> specific re-check or site inspection where the other party both objects and adduces evidence -> site inspection where there is no signed certification and no drawings -> and where inspection still cannot determine the position and the applicant has no valid evidence, refusal of measurement, stated in the opinion as an 'item not susceptible to assessment' (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.3.6). |
5. Procedural requirements for retrospectively certified quantity sheets
- Capacity and authority: they must be signed by the site management personnel of both parties within the duties agreed in the contract (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 12.2.1); a certification signed by the supervising engineer alone can also stand, but ratification by the employer should be added.
- Content requirements: stating the part and its geometry, the quantity and the calculation, with drawings or photos and the original certified vouchers attached; where a site record states both quantity and price, calculation follows that quantity and price (GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.9.1 item 1); where only a total price is stated without detail, calculation follows the total price (item 4); for sundry works where the recorded quantity differs from the quantity actually completed, calculation follows the quantity actually completed (item 5).
- Curing defects: where the employer merely signs to prove receipt without signifying agreement, and the contractor has evidence that the work covered by the site record was completed, the assessor may issue an assessment opinion and list it separately for the commissioning party to judge (clause 5.9.2 item 1); where there is neither quantity nor price but only a statement of the work done, the parties negotiate; failing negotiation, the assessor makes a professional analysis per the principles and methods agreed in the contract and issues an inferred opinion (item 2).
- Time limits: submit within the contractual time limit; where the employer neither checks nor comments in time, the deemed approval rules apply (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 7.1.5 and 7.1.6).
6. Interface with measurement of quantities from drawings or from actuals
- Measurement from drawings is the rule: quantities are re-measured from the as-built construction drawings provided by the employer and the variation instructions issued and confirmed, under the national and trade quantity take-off standards and supplementary calculation rules agreed in the contract (clause 7.2.1). Where concealed works lack measurement records, first compute the 'drawn quantities' in full from the as-built drawings plus design changes plus site records, then support with the chain of evidence the parts beyond the drawings (over-excavation and backfill, ground treatment, actual sections larger than the design section).
- Parts beyond the design dimensions without the support of a variation or a site record are generally not measured at final account; only items whose measurement rules provide otherwise, or where the design is silent and measurement follows actuals or site records, are measured from actuals.
- Measurement results 'deemed accepted' may serve as the basis for calculating payment but cannot be relied on to claim that the works were handed over as conforming (clause 7.1.5) - the two cannot substitute for each other.
Applicable boundaries
- Applies to measurement and final account disputes over concealed works under construction contracts (the GF-2017-0201 model text system); where the particular conditions prescribe different notice periods, postponement or procedure, those prevail.
- The self-bearing of exposure costs for covering without permission is not conditional on quality (5.3.4): conforming quality only excuses quality liability and does not shift the exposure and reinstatement costs.
- Where the contract is silent, GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended national standard; its 'deemed approval' and 'signed confirmation' clauses bind only through incorporation by the contract; in litigation the court may refer the matter to judicial construction cost expert assessment.
- With no signed certification, no drawings and no possible inspection, there is a real risk that the claim is classed as an 'item not susceptible to assessment' and refused measurement; priority should then go to securing a site inspection and a reconciliation between the parties.
- Local supervision standards may set different notice periods for concealed-works inspection; check the standard of the project location and the particular conditions.
Further reading
GF-2017-0201 'Construction Contract (Model Text)' clause 4.4 [Agreement or determination], clause 5.3 [Inspection of concealed works] (5.3.1 contractor self-inspection, 5.3.2 inspection procedure, 5.3.3 re-inspection, 5.3.4 covering without permission), clause 5.4 [treatment of non-conforming works], clause 5.5 [testing of quality disputes]; GB/T 50500-2024 'Standard for BOQ pricing of construction works' clauses 7.1.5, 7.1.6, 7.1.8, 7.2.1, 12.2.1; GB/T 50319-2013 'Code for construction project supervision' clause 5.2.14 and Forms B.0.7, B.0.8; T/ZBD 100.4-2023 'Guidelines for construction cost expert assessment practice' clause 4.3.6; GB/T 51262-2017 'Code for construction cost expert assessment' clauses 5.9.1, 5.9.2; 'Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works' (2017 revision) article 30; Contract Law article 278 [acceptance of concealed works] (now carried over by Civil Code article 798).
Keywords
- concealed works
- 计量记录
- 隐蔽工程验收记录
- 私自覆盖
- 剥露检查
- 事后补签认量单
- deemed acceptance / deemed approval
- 按图计量