Settlement pricing when the confirmed price of a provisionally priced material differs from published price information: the procedurally formed confirmed price (net award price, or employer-confirmed enquiry price) replaces the provisional sum, published prices serving only as the contractually agreed base or a provisional fallback in disputes
Settlement follows the confirmed price formed under the contractual procedure - for mandatory-tender items, the net-of-VAT material award price replaces the provisional price; otherwise the employer-confirmed (or jointly enquired) net price does (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 8.4.1, 8.4.5); published price information neither replaces the confirmed price nor caps or floors it - it applies only where the contract makes it the base, or where a period market price is missing or the dispute is large, provisionally, 'to be trued up in later payments against actual market prices' (Appendix A clause A.2.2). The difference adjusts only the material provisional price (net) within the all-in unit rate, other cost heads unchanged, carrying VAT but never overheads or profit (clauses 8.4.6, 3.3.5 item 4).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第2.0.14、3.3.5、8.4.1~8.4.6、10.3.2条及App. A 第A.2.2、A.2.5条
- GB/T 50875-2013 · Standard glossary of project costs 第2.2.60、2.1.16条
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023 · Work Guideline for Settlement Audit of Construction Works 第3.1.7条
- DB 61/T 5126-2025《建设工程工程量清单计价标准》(陕西省)及配套《陕西省建设工程费用规则》
Positioning
Whether, when the confirmed price of a provisionally priced material (or equipment) differs from the authority's published price information, settlement follows the confirmed price - and the confirmation routes (two classes), the pricing basis and the lawful place of published prices.
Core conclusions
Conclusion: settle at the confirmed price; published prices neither substitute for it nor set a lower-or-higher cap.
1. The provisional price starts as a listed estimate, not a published price
- GB/T 50875-2013 clause 2.2.60: the provisional price is "the unit price of materials and equipment that will certainly occur but cannot be priced at contract signing, and the price of specialist works, given by the tenderer in the BOQ".
- GB/T 50500-2024 term 2.0.14: the material provisional price is "the net-of-VAT price at which the employer, in the BOQ, estimates materials required by the drawings whose standard, specification or price cannot be fixed at tender, delivered to site"; "material provisional prices include works equipment".
2. Two lawful sources of the replacing price
(1) Mandatory-tender items - the award price replaces. Clause 8.4.1: "Provisionally priced materials and specialist works within mandatory tendering scope are replaced by the tendered net material price and/or the VAT-inclusive specialist subcontract price, adjusting the contract price. (1) Material provisional prices are replaced by the net award price; (2) specialist subcontracts by the VAT-inclusive award price." Material provisional prices are net (ex-VAT), specialist provisional prices VAT-inclusive - opposite treatments, never mixed. (2) Others - the employer-confirmed enquiry price replaces. Clause 8.4.5: "Provisionally priced materials outside mandatory tendering may be market-enquired or freely quoted by the contractor; once the employer confirms, the net price replaces the provisional price - or both parties jointly enquire and confirm a net price - with the VAT change computed and the contract price adjusted." (3) Timing procedure (deciding whether a confirmed price exists). Appendix A clause A.2.5: employer-recognised purchase prices as period market prices require the contractor to submit quantities and unit prices before purchase; the employer confirms within the agreed period; batches may be weighted averages; employer silence past the period is deemed approval usable for adjustment.
3. Precedence when the confirmed and published prices differ
- Confirmed price first. Clauses 8.4.1 / 8.4.5 give only two replacements - award net price, and confirmed / jointly-enquired net price; the standard grants published prices no replacing status and no cap or floor.
- First lawful place of published prices - contractually agreed base. Where the contract expressly makes published prices the confirmation or adjustment base (clause 3.3.5 requires the sources and rules to be fixed in the contract), the contract governs - contract precedence, not published-price precedence.
- Second lawful place - provisional fallback in disputes (not final). A.2.2: where no period market price exists or the dispute is large, the authority's published price information may be used provisionally, "trued up in later payments against actual market prices" - a transitional computation, eventually returning to actual / confirmed prices.
- What published prices are: GB/T 50875-2013 clause 2.1.16 - price information published by cost authorities (labour, materials, equipment, machine-shifts, indices and indicators), not the transaction price of any individual item.
4. Only the material provisional price inside the rate is replaced
- Clause 8.4.6: "adjustments touch only the material provisional price of the all-in unit rate; other costs in that item's rate should not adjust"; the adjusted rate serves clauses 8.2, 8.3 and 8.9 (BOQ errors, provisional sums, variations).
- Clause 3.3.5 item 4: differences in labour, materials and fuel/power "carry VAT only, never overheads or profit".
- At the final account the adjustment is a listed item: clause 10.3.2 item 4 - "provisional price adjustments: 1) materials; 2) specialist works (general-contract projects)".
- Local parallel: the Shaanxi cost rules (with DB 61/T 5126-2025) - "material provisional prices adjust at the parties' confirmed price, the adjustment treated as a difference carrying VAT only", prices and quantities confirmed by the employer before adjustment.
Applicable boundaries
- For BOQ-priced works with material provisional prices (equipment included); specialist provisional prices are VAT-inclusive and are replaced wholesale by the award price - the "adjust only the material net price" rule does not apply.
- Mandatory-tender items replaced by self-enquiry without tendering breach clause 8.4.1 - such prices cannot ground settlement.
- Confirmed prices must form procedurally: no pre-purchase submission, later back-signed confirmation fails the review basis of T/ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 3.1.7 ("only price-change costs and the matching tax adjust; nothing else").
- Express contractual terms on confirmation methods or bases govern, short of mandatory law.
- Published prices serve only as the agreed base or the A.2.2 provisional computation - never directly as the settlement unit price.
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 terms 2.0.14, clauses 3.3.5(4), 8.4.1~8.4.6, 10.3.2(4), Appendix A A.2.2, A.2.5.
- GB/T 50875-2013 clauses 2.2.60, 2.1.16; T/ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 3.1.7; Shaanxi cost rules and DB 61/T 5126-2025.