Cost items expressly excluded from the all-in unit rate in BOQ-based pricing (VAT, statutory levies and fees, main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions, provisional sums, employer-borne costs, statutory safety provisions), the correct billing position of each, and audit identification of mixed allocation
Under GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 2.0.9 the all-in unit rate 'includes labour cost, material cost, plant and small tools cost, management cost, profit and risk costs within a defined range, and excludes VAT', and Clause 3.1.6 makes it a 'fully inclusive price excluding VAT'. Hence VAT (charged at the summary level under Clause 3.2.11), main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions (Clauses 2.0.17, 3.2.9 and 4.2.6, listed separately in the bill of provisional sums and other charges by item or by percentage rate), provisional sums (Clauses 2.0.13 and 8.3.1, at the employer's disposal and not owned by the contractor), the price of employer-supplied materials with their delivery and unloading charges and the material cost of the employer-borne permitted wastage (Clauses 3.2.4 and 6.2.4), and statutory safety provisions (Clause 3.2.5, non-competitive and separately listed in the bill of preliminaries) must not enter the all-in unit rate of work items; the 2024 edition cost composition no longer has a 'statutory levies and fees' heading (the five insurances and one housing fund for production workers now go into labour cost, and those for management staff plus the construction effluent fee go into overheads), so adding a separate statutory levies heading and charging it again is an error.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 第 2.0.9、2.0.13、2.0.17 条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第 3.1.6、3.2.2、3.2.4、3.2.5、3.2.9、3.2.11、3.6.1、3.7.4 条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第 4.2.6 条、第 6.2.4 条、第 8.3.1 条、App. E Table E.4.5、App. G.1 Table G.1.1
- GB/T 50875-2013 第 2.2.58、2.2.59 条
- GB 50500-2013 第 2.0.8 条
- GB/T 51095-2015 第 5.3.8 条
- DB42/T 823—2021 第 6.3.8 条
- DB14/T 1319—2021 第 3.4 条
Topic positioning
This card answers the reverse question most often asked in BOQ pricing audits: which costs are expressly excluded from the all-in unit rate of BOQ items, the correct destination of each (in which bill, at which summary level, charged by what method), how they are absorbed under the fully loaded all-in rate convention, and how 'mixed allocation' (spreading separately billed items into the unit rate while setting up separate headings for items that should be absorbed) is identified. It draws on GB/T 50500-2024 together with GB/T 50875-2013 and GB/T 51095-2015, flagging the comparable cost composition clause numbers.
Core conclusions
1. Fix the convention first (with no fixed convention, the exclusion list is bound to be wrong)
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 2.0.9 (term 'all-in unit rate'): the all-in unit rate is 'the cost required to complete one unit quantity of a BOQ item, taking comprehensive account of influencing factors such as technical standards and codes, construction period, construction sequence, construction conditions, geography and climate, as well as risks within the agreed scope and band. The all-in unit rate of a BOQ item includes labour cost, material cost, plant and small tools cost, management cost, profit and risk costs within a defined range, and excludes VAT'; it also states that 'VAT is a price-exclusive tax and the all-in unit rate does not contain VAT'.
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.1.6: 'The all-in unit rate and the price of BOQ items should be a fully inclusive price excluding VAT, composed of labour cost, material cost, plant and small tools cost, management cost, profit and the like, including the risk costs within the agreed or reasonable scope of the relevant BOQ item and the cost of indispensable auxiliary work; the taxes of BOQ items should be entered under VAT, but the provisional sum for nominated specialist subcontract works in the bill of provisional sums and other charges already contains VAT, and its corresponding tax should not be charged again in the VAT of the bill of quantities.'
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.2.2 (positive list): the all-in unit rate should include (1) the costs needed to satisfy national and industry technical standards and codes; (2) the costs arising from errors and omissions in the BOQ under lump-sum contracts; (3) the costs of the construction tasks necessary to meet completion and handover requirements and of their indispensable auxiliary work; (4) the costs caused by construction sequence, construction conditions, environment, climate and similar factors; (5) risk costs within the scope and band agreed in the contract or specified in Section 3.3. Risk costs beyond the agreed band / scope and contract-level costs are not included.
- Comparison with the 2013 edition: under GB 50500-2013 Clause 2.0.8 the all-in unit rate likewise consists of 'labour cost, material and engineering equipment cost, plant and small tools cost, overheads, profit and risk costs within a defined range' (the synonymous original sentence appears in GB/T 50875-2013 Clause 2.2.58, 'all-in unit rate'); statutory levies and taxes are likewise outside the all-in unit rate (the 2013 edition used a business tax and surcharges pricing convention). When verifying specific clause numbers, the original edition text prevails.
2. Enumerated excluded costs and their correct destinations
| No. | Cost that must not enter the all-in unit rate | Clause basis | Correct destination |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | VAT (taxes and duties) | 2024 edition Clauses 2.0.9 and 3.1.6 | Listed separately at the summary level: Clause 3.2.11, 'VAT should take the total amounts of the bills of work items, of preliminaries and of provisional sums and other charges (excluding the provisional sum for nominated specialist subcontract works) as the calculation base, multiplied by the VAT rate prescribed by the government authority in charge to compute the tax' |
| 2 | The 'statutory levies and fees' heading (social insurance, housing fund, construction effluent fee) | The Clause 3.1.6 composition (2024 edition) no longer contains a statutory levies item | The 2024 edition abolishes the separate statutory levies heading: the five insurances and one housing fund for production workers go into labour cost, and those for management staff plus the construction effluent fee (since adjusted to the environmental protection tax) go into overheads; under the 2013 edition they are listed and charged separately and must not be treated as competitive costs |
| 3 | Main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions | Clause 2.0.17 (term), Clause 3.2.9, Clause 4.2.6 item 6, Annex E Table E.4.5 | Listed as an independent item in the bill of provisional sums and other charges, 'which may be measured by item or by percentage rate'; when priced by percentage rate the provisional price is the preferable pricing base, C1 = A1 x B; at final account the confirmed calculation base applies, C2 = A2 x B |
| 4 | Provisional sums | Clause 2.0.13 (term), Clause 8.3.1, Clause 4.2.6 item 1; GB/T 50875-2013 Clause 2.2.59 | Listed in the bill of provisional sums and other charges, held by the employer and used at the employer's instruction; 'it does not belong to the contractor and will not necessarily be incurred ... unused provisional sums belong to the employer at final account' |
| 5 | Provisional sum for nominated specialist subcontract works; dayworks | Clause 4.2.6 items 2 and 5; Clauses 3.1.6 and 3.2.11 | Listed separately by category / discipline and by item in the bill of provisional sums and other charges; the provisional sum for nominated specialist works is a VAT-inclusive price and must be deducted from the VAT calculation base, with its tax not charged again |
| 6 | The price of employer-supplied materials, their delivery and unloading charges, and the material cost of the employer-borne permitted wastage | Clauses 3.2.4, 3.6.1 and 6.2.4 | The material cost does not enter the bill of work items; the employer states the name, grade, specification and model, delivery method and place in the tender documents and the item description; the corresponding management and coordination responsibility is charged as main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions in the bill of provisional sums and other charges |
| 7 | Statutory safety provisions (mandatory HSE provisions) | Clause 3.2.5 | Listed in the bill of preliminaries; 'a non-competitive item whose pricing must comply with the relevant provisions of national, provincial and sector authorities'; it must not be spread into the all-in unit rate of work items |
Key original sentence (boundary of employer-supplied materials, Clause 3.2.4): 'For BOQ items where the employer supplies the materials and the contractor installs them, the all-in unit rate should include the installation wastage the contractor itself bears, but not the price of the employer-supplied materials, nor the wastage costs borne by the employer as agreed in Table G.1.1 (schedule of employer-supplied materials) of Annex G.1 of this standard, nor the corresponding main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions; where the employer supplies materials and the material supplier is responsible for installation while the contractor does not install but provides attendance and coordination services, the bill of quantities should not list the item nor compute its all-in unit rate, but the corresponding main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions should be computed in the bill of provisional sums and other charges.'
Corresponding rule on the tender pricing side (Clause 6.2.4): tenderers should price BOQ items with employer-supplied materials as an installation price, which 'should satisfy the requirements of the quantities on labour price changes, on the permitted wastage rate stipulated in the tender documents, and on the contractual risk of over-consuming materials for the tenderer's own reasons. The all-in unit rate and the tender total should not include the cost of the supplier of the employer-supplied materials transporting the relevant materials to the delivery place and completing unloading'; the installation price scope is 'all costs from receiving at the delivery place the materials supplied by the supplier of the employer-supplied materials until they are installed in the position required by the design, including costs of secondary handling on site after receipt of the supplied materials and the cost of over-consumption of the relevant materials offered by the tenderer itself', but it excludes 'the supplier's costs of transporting the materials to the delivery place and completing unloading, and the cost of the portion of materials corresponding to the permitted wastage rate stipulated in the tender documents'.
Price deduction when employer supply replaces contractor supply (Clause 3.7.4): where materials contractually to be provided by the contractor are changed to employer supply and the contractor accepts in writing, 'the material cost contained in the all-in unit rate of the relevant BOQ item and its purchasing and custody charges should be deducted, the other costs contained in the all-in unit rate should not be adjusted, the BOQ item rate after deduction should be the installation all-in rate of that item, and the VAT on the deducted amount contained in the contract price should be reduced', with main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions and VAT further payable under Section 8.5.
Red lines on the scope of main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions (Clause 2.0.17 + Clause 3.2.9): they cover charges for main-contractor services for employer-supplied materials, for specialist subcontract works within the contract scope commissioned by the employer to parties other than the contractor, and for specialist works outside the contract scope directly let by the employer and not executed by the contractor; 'profit should be included. Main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions should not be charged for specialist works and labour-only works subcontracted by the contractor itself'; Clause 3.2.9 makes clear that they are the 'VAT-exclusive price of the relevant BOQ items', computed under Clause 4.2.6.
3. How these costs are absorbed under the fully loaded all-in rate convention
- GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.3.8: 'The work-item cost of building works budgets should be aggregated from each line item quantity multiplied by its all-in unit rate ... the all-in unit rate of each line item should include labour cost, material cost, plant cost, management cost, profit, statutory levies and taxes' (a tax-inclusive fully loaded convention covering statutory levies and taxes).
- DB42/T 823-2021 Clause 6.3.8: the same wording becomes 'it is preferable to adopt a fully loaded all-in rate including labour cost, material cost, plant cost, management cost, profit, statutory levies and taxes', explaining that 'given the current mismatch among the national BOQ standard, the consultancy standard and the provincial quota system ... a fully loaded all-in rate is required as preferable'.
- Highway sector example (DB14/T 1319-2021 Clause 3.4): the all-in unit rate is 'the labour cost, material cost, construction plant cost, permanent equipment procurement cost, preliminaries, overheads, statutory levies, profit and taxes, plus the risk costs within the contract-agreed scope, needed to complete one specified BOQ line item' - statutory levies and taxes are included, and even permanent equipment procurement cost and preliminaries, so it must not be mixed with the building BOQ convention.
- Absorption under the two conventions: fully loaded all-in rate = incomplete all-in rate (the Clause 3.1.6 composition of the 2024 edition) + statutory levies + taxes, with statutory levies and taxes absorbed into the rate; the summary level must then set up no further statutory levies or taxes headings, otherwise double counting results; conversely, under the Clause 3.1.6 convention the rate excludes VAT, VAT is listed separately at the summary level, and any tax appearing inside the rate is misplaced.
- Easily confused point: the 2024 edition 'pre-tax fully inclusive price' is not the same thing as the trade habit of the 'fully loaded all-in rate'; the former is 'all costs included but excluding tax', the latter 'including statutory levies + taxes, tax-inclusive'. The two adding conventions differ and cannot be interchanged (compare Clause 3.1.6 with GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.3.8).
4. Audit checklist for mixed allocation (duplication / omission)
- VAT appearing in the all-in rate build-up sheets -> misplaced, breaching Clauses 2.0.9 and 3.1.6.
- A further 'statutory levies and fees' heading charged at the summary level under the 2024 edition -> double charging: the Clause 3.1.6 composition no longer contains a statutory levies item, the former statutory levies content having entered the all-in rate through labour cost and overheads (some provincial 2024 edition cost norms expressly 'abolish the separate listing of statutory levies'). When reviewing 2024-convention outputs, 'social insurance appearing inside the rate' is not itself a misplacement; it is setting up a separate heading and charging twice that is the misplacement.
- The price of employer-supplied materials or their delivery and unloading charges contained in the all-in rate of work items -> breaching Clauses 3.2.4 and 6.2.4; charging main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions at the same time in the bill of provisional sums and other charges is normal and required, not duplication.
- Main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions or provisional sums spread into the all-in unit rate of work items -> breaching the itemisation rules of Clause 4.2.6 (both should be independently listed in the bill of provisional sums and other charges).
- The provisional sum for nominated specialist subcontract works taken into the VAT calculation base -> breaching Clauses 3.1.6 and 3.2.11 (it is itself VAT-inclusive).
- Statutory safety provisions spread pro rata into the all-in unit rate of work items -> breaching Clause 3.2.5 (a non-competitive item, charged at the prescribed percentage rate in the bill of preliminaries).
- Risk costs beyond the contract-agreed scope and band pre-loaded in the rate -> inconsistent with Clause 3.2.2 item (5) and Section 3.3; the portion beyond the band belongs to the adjustable scope and should not be pre-fixed.
- Unused provisional sums left in the sums due to the contractor at final account -> breaching Clause 8.3.1 (the unused portion belongs to the employer).
Applicable boundaries
- This card addresses the 'all-in unit rate of BOQ items' under the GB/T 50500-2024 BOQ pricing system, and applies to the preparation and review of BOQ-priced outputs in building and municipal works adopting that standard.
- Different sector conventions: in the highway (e.g. DB14/T 1319-2021), water conservancy and railway sectors the all-in rate is often a fully loaded convention including statutory levies and taxes, sometimes even permanent equipment procurement cost and preliminaries; confirm the industry standard before citing, and never apply this card's exclusion list directly to cross-sector outputs.
- Different edition conventions: the 2013 and 2024 editions treat statutory levies differently (separately listed in 2013; absorbed into labour cost and overheads in 2024); for cross-edition review, first establish the contractually agreed pricing edition, then judge whether a cost is misplaced.
- Main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions do not apply to specialist works and labour-only works subcontracted by the contractor itself; where the supplier is responsible for installation and the contractor only provides attendance and coordination, the item is not listed in the bill and no all-in unit rate is computed.
- This card's conclusions are on the BOQ pricing convention; cost compositions for quota-based pricing, estimates and budgets follow the relevant cost norms / pricing rules, and this card's exclusion list does not apply.
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024, China national pricing standard for BOQ: terms Clause 2.0.9 (all-in unit rate), Clause 2.0.13 (provisional sums), Clause 2.0.17 (main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions); basic provisions Clauses 3.1.6, 3.2.2, 3.2.4, 3.2.5, 3.2.9, 3.2.11, 3.6.1 and 3.7.4; BOQ preparation Clause 4.2.6; tender pricing preparation Clause 6.2.4; contract price adjustment Clause 8.3.1; Annex E Table E.4.5 (pricing of main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions) and Annex G.1 Table G.1.1 (schedule of employer-supplied materials).
- GB/T 50875-2013, terminology standard for construction cost: Clause 2.2.58 (all-in unit rate) and Clause 2.2.59 (provisional sums).
- GB/T 51095-2015 (construction cost consultancy code) Clause 5.3.8; DB42/T 823-2021 Clause 6.3.8; DB14/T 1319-2021 (highway standard BOQ and measurement) Clause 3.4.
- Also verify the contractually agreed pricing edition and the current local cost norms on statutory levies and statutory safety provisions.