Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Determining the hierarchy of authority when technical disclosure documents, construction schemes, and actual site practices are inconsistent

Hierarchy of authority of construction documents: the construction contract, design drawings, and mandatory standards are the highest authority; approved construction schemes are the basis for execution; technical disclosures are downstream refinements of the scheme and must not exceed it; actual site practices can only supersede written documents when a change has been approved through the original approval procedure. Practices that violate mandatory standards or alter the design without authorization are invalid in all cases, and costs incurred without a formal change order must not be approved for payment.

Applicable Codes

  • 建设工程质量管理条例 第28条
  • GB 55032-2022 第3.1.4条
  • T SDJZXH 004.1-2022 第10.6.1条
  • DB11/T 1745-2020 第8.4.1条
  • T ZSQX 018-2022 第8.2.6条
  • TB 10443-2010 第7.5节
  • TB 10402-2019 第10.1节

Topic Positioning

Answers the construction management question "when technical disclosures, construction method statements, and actual site practices are inconsistent, which prevails," establishing the hierarchy of authority among documents and scenario-based handling rules for on-site dispute resolution, change procedure management, and settlement risk self-inspection.

Core Conclusions

  1. Hierarchy of authority: the construction contract, design drawings, and mandatory standards are the highest authority; an approved construction method statement (including dedicated method statements) is the basis for execution; technical disclosures must be prepared based on the approved method statement and must not exceed it.
  2. Disclosure inconsistent with the method statement: the approved method statement prevails; if the method statement is considered inapplicable, it must be revised and re-approved through the original approval procedure before re-disclosure—disclosure content must not be changed privately.
  3. Site practice inconsistent with documents falls into two cases: where the practice is better AND a change has been processed through the original approval procedure, the amended document prevails (changes must go through the original approval procedure); where the practice was altered without approval, it is invalid—acceptance is judged against drawings and the method statement, and at settlement, costs arising from alterations to the method statement lacking approved review procedures, failure to build to drawings, or unreasonable construction methodology and site organization measures caused by the contractor's own fault are not approved for payment, with consequences borne by the contractor.
  4. Method statements/disclosures must not exceed the design: the contractor must build to drawings and must not modify the design without authorization; upon discovering drawing errors, it should promptly raise them in writing and follow the design change procedure.
  5. Two red lines: mandatory standards cannot be exceeded at any level; anything involving design changes (dimensions, materials, methods, functions) must first go through a design change and be approved before implementation.

Applicable Boundaries

Applies to general construction technical management for building, municipal, rail transit, and railway works; where the contract has special agreements on the effectiveness requirements for changes and payment approvals, those agreements prevail. This card does not replace judgment under specific project contract terms. When site practice deviates from documents, same-day documentation (construction logs, supervision diaries, photo/video records) is key evidence in disputes to prove "when and by whom it was approved."

Further Reading

See Articles 28 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects; GB 55032-2022 General Code for Construction Quality Control of Building and Municipal Engineering, Article 3.1.4; T/SDJZXH 004.1-2022 Standard for Supervision of Urban Rail Transit Engineering, Article 10.6.1 (scope of site payment approvals that must not be signed); for disclosure preparation basis, see DB11/T 1745-2020 Technical Regulation for Construction Technology Management of Building Works, Article 8.4.1, and T/ZSQX 018-2022 Guide for Whole-Process Technical Disclosure of Construction Projects, Article 8.2.6; documentation requirements for construction records and supervision diaries are in TB 10443-2010 Section 7.5 and TB 10402-2019 Section 10.1.

Keywords

Cited By